St. Louis CITY SC defeat Toronto FC 3-1: Match Recap, Betting Results & AiQ Picks
Sat, Sep 19, 2026 · MLS · Toronto FC 1, St. Louis CITY SC 3
St. Louis CITY SC defeated Toronto FC 3–1 on Saturday, September 19 at Energizer Park. The match went over the 3.5-goal total, finishing with four goals. AiQ's moneyline pick on St. Louis CITY SC at –137 won, though the model's under on total goals lost.
Toronto FC vs. St. Louis CITY SC final score and match recap
St. Louis CITY SC scored first and led 1–0 at halftime. Toronto FC pulled one back in the second half, but St. Louis added two more to close out a 3–1 victory.
Did Toronto FC vs. St. Louis CITY SC go over or under the goals total?
The match went over 3.5, finishing with four goals. The first half produced one goal; the second half added three. AiQ had selected the under at 3.5 with 60% confidence, which resulted in a loss.
How did AiQ's Toronto FC vs. St. Louis CITY SC predictions do?
AiQ posted a 3–4 record across all graded picks on this match.
- Moneyline: St. Louis CITY SC at –137 — WIN (+$72.99 on a $100 bet)
- Total: Under 3.5 — LOSS
- Player props: 2–3
AiQ correctly identified the winner but missed the total and three of five player prop selections.
Toronto FC vs. St. Louis CITY SC player prop results
AiQ's player prop record was 2–3.
- Damion Downs (St. Louis CITY SC) under 3.5 shots; actual 1 — WIN
- Simon Becher (St. Louis CITY SC) under 3.5 shots; actual 4 — LOSS
- Tomas Ostrak (St. Louis CITY SC) under 2.5 shots; actual 0 — WIN
- Damion Downs (St. Louis CITY SC) to record a goal anytime at +140; actual 0 — LOSS
- Damion Downs (St. Louis CITY SC) over 1.5 shots on target at +145; actual 0 — LOSS
Downs stayed well below his shot expectations, while Becher exceeded his limit.
Toronto FC vs. St. Louis CITY SC game prop results: both teams to score and draw no bet
- Both teams to score: Yes (paid –215)
- Draw no bet: St. Louis CITY SC cashed (paid –275)
Toronto FC vs. St. Louis CITY SC odds: sportsbook value and line movement
The three-way moneyline closed at Toronto FC +305, Draw +297, and St. Louis CITY SC –137. After vig removal, the implied win probabilities were 23% for Toronto, 23% for a draw, and 54% for St. Louis, with a bookmaker margin of 7.7%. St. Louis CITY SC won the moneyline at –137, paying $72.99 on a $100 bet.
AiQ's pre-game expected value calculation placed the market at –3.7% using a –150 price (best at BetMGM), indicating the price was slightly unfavorable despite the side being a clear favorite. The market's implied 58% probability matched AiQ's calibrated estimate, confirming alignment between the model and the sportsbook.
Toronto FC and St. Louis CITY SC betting trends: 2026 season
Toronto FC sits at 6–11–9 through 26 matches, with a 4–8–2 record at home and 2–3–7 on the road. Their over/under line has hit the total 15 times and gone under 11 times. The club is on a two-game losing streak after results of L, L, W, D, D in their last five.
St. Louis CITY SC holds a 12–8–6 record after 26 contests, posting an 8–3–2 home mark and a 4–5–4 away/neutral split. Their total has gone over 14 times and under 12 times. The club's recent form is W, W, D, W, D, extending a two-game winning streak.
What's next for Toronto FC and St. Louis CITY SC?
Toronto FC will host CF Montréal on Saturday, October 10. St. Louis CITY SC returns to Energizer Park to host LA Galaxy on Sunday, October 11.