Columbus Blue Jackets vs New York Islanders Prediction, Picks & Odds — Nov 17
Tue, Nov 17, 7:00 PM ET · UBS Arena · NHL
Open the game card for live odds, every market and the full prediction.
Columbus Blue Jackets at New York Islanders is on Tuesday, November 17, 2026, at UBS Arena. Averaged over the outcomes the betting lines imply, the projected score is Columbus Blue Jackets 3, New York Islanders 3. That is an average, not a pick.
The story
The Columbus Blue Jackets have won 7 of their 18 games this season, losing the last four. The New York Islanders have won 9 of their 19 games this season, winning two of the last five. When these teams last met, on March 22, 2026, the New York Islanders won 1-0 at home.
Matchups to watch
- The probable starting goalies are Cam Talbot (confirmed, .906 save percentage in the 2026-27 season) for the Columbus Blue Jackets and Ilya Sorokin (confirmed, .915 save percentage in the 2026-27 season) for the New York Islanders.
- An uphill climb on the power play. The Columbus Blue Jackets scored on 18.2% of their power plays this season, the 7th lowest in the NHL, and the New York Islanders allowed opponents to score on 14.1% of their power plays, tied for the 4th lowest.
Moneyline
The betting market, with the margin removed, gives New York Islanders a 56.7% chance to beat Columbus Blue Jackets. AiQ's moneyline pick is the side the consensus favors. The best price, -139 at Caesars, is priced below the fair price of -131 (−2.6% value).
Total
The betting market, with the margin removed, puts the over 5.5 goals at 52.2% and the under at 47.8%. That is near a coin flip, and AiQ's read is the market's own, so AiQ has no edge on the total. AiQ's projected total, 6.0 goals, comes from the same market prices, so it adds nothing to them.
Puck line
The betting market, with the margin removed, gives Columbus Blue Jackets +1.5 a 66.7% chance to cover and New York Islanders -1.5 33.3%. AiQ's read matches the market price, so AiQ has no edge on the puck line.
Trends in play
Recent results against the puck line back the New York Islanders. The Columbus Blue Jackets failed to cover the puck line in 4 straight games.
Recent totals lean over. The New York Islanders went over the total in 7 of their last 10 games.
These come from the closing lines of this season and last. They are context, not the reason for AiQ's picks, and the books price them in.