Milwaukee Brewers defeat St. Louis Cardinals 3-2: Recap, Betting Results & AiQ Picks
Sat, Sep 26, 2026 · MLB · St. Louis Cardinals 2, Milwaukee Brewers 3
Milwaukee Brewers defeated St. Louis Cardinals 3-2 on Saturday at American Family Field. The Cardinals covered the +1.5 spread despite the loss, and the game finished under the 7.5 total with just five combined runs.
St. Louis Cardinals vs. Milwaukee Brewers final score and game recap
Quinn Mathews started for St. Louis and Dustin May for Milwaukee. The Cardinals scored in the second and third innings to build a 2-0 lead. Milwaukee answered with a run in the third, then broke through with two runs in the fifth to take a 3-2 advantage. Neither team scored again through the eighth inning, preserving Milwaukee's one-run margin.
Who covered the spread in St. Louis Cardinals vs. Milwaukee Brewers?
St. Louis covered the +1.5 spread as an underdog, winning the bet despite losing the game. Milwaukee, listed at -1.5, won by exactly one run—the narrowest possible margin for a favorite to fail to cover. The spread held steady from open to close.
Did St. Louis Cardinals vs. Milwaukee Brewers go over or under the total?
The game went under 7.5, finishing with five runs. Scoring concentrated in two innings for St. Louis and three for Milwaukee, leaving the total 2.5 runs short of the line. The total line did not move.
How did AiQ's St. Louis Cardinals vs. Milwaukee Brewers predictions do?
AiQ posted a 64-29 record across every graded pick on this game.
- Moneyline: Milwaukee Brewers at -162 – WIN (+$61.73 on a $100 bet)
- Spread: St. Louis Cardinals +1.5 – WIN
- Total: Under 7.5 – WIN
- Player props: 63-29
AiQ correctly identified the moneyline favorite, the underdog covering the spread, and the low-scoring nature of the contest. The model struggled with individual prop lines, a common pattern in player-specific markets.
St. Louis Cardinals vs. Milwaukee Brewers player prop results
AiQ's player-prop record was 63-29. Among the listed picks:
- Thomas Saggese under 1.5 hits + runs + RBIs at -176 – actual 2 – LOSS
- JJ Wetherholt over 0.5 hits at -169 – actual 0 – LOSS
- Jake Bauers over 1.5 hits + runs + RBIs at +103 – actual 0 – LOSS
- Jake Bauers over 0.5 total bases at -150 – actual 0 – LOSS
- Alec Burleson over 1.5 hits + runs + RBIs at +106 – actual 3 – WIN
- William Contreras over 0.5 RBIs at +166 – actual 0 – LOSS
- Gary Sanchez under 0.5 home runs – actual 0 – WIN
- Brice Turang over 1.5 hits + runs + RBIs at -105 – actual 4 – WIN
- Ivan Herrera over 1.5 total bases at +156 – actual 0 – LOSS
- William Contreras over 1.5 hits + runs + RBIs at -115 – actual 1 – LOSS
- Alec Burleson over 1.5 total bases at +145 – actual 4 – WIN
- Brice Turang over 0.5 hits at -190 – actual 1 – WIN
Cardinals hitters largely underperformed their prop projections, while Brewers bats—particularly Turang—exceeded expectations.
St. Louis Cardinals vs. Milwaukee Brewers game prop results: first five innings and team totals
- First-five-innings total 4.5: Over (paid +106); five runs were scored
- First-five-innings moneyline: Milwaukee Brewers won the first five innings (paid -166)
- St. Louis Cardinals team total 3.5: Under (paid -130); they scored 2
- Milwaukee Brewers team total 3.5: Under (paid +114); they scored 3
Milwaukee's early offensive burst cleared the first-five-innings over, but both teams fell short of their individual run totals.
St. Louis Cardinals vs. Milwaukee Brewers odds: sportsbook value and line movement
The moneyline showed St. Louis at +136 and Milwaukee at -162, implying a 41 percent chance for the Cardinals and 59 percent for the Brewers after vigorish removal. The bookmaker margin was 4.2 percent. Milwaukee's -162 moneyline returned $61.73 on a $100 wager. AiQ's pre-game expected-value calculation placed the Brewers at -152 with negative expected value of -0.9 percent. The spread and total lines remained unchanged throughout.
St. Louis Cardinals and Milwaukee Brewers betting trends: 2026 season
St. Louis sits at 77-83 through 160 games, posting a 38-42 home record and 39-41 away. They have lost three straight games.
Milwaukee leads at 99-58 through 157 games, with a dominant 52-25 home mark and 47-33 away. They have won four consecutive games.
What's next for St. Louis Cardinals and Milwaukee Brewers?
Milwaukee will host the Padres or Cubs on Saturday, October 3.