Pittsburgh Pirates defeat St. Louis Cardinals 2-1: Recap, Betting Results & AiQ Picks
Thu, Sep 24, 2026 · MLB · St. Louis Cardinals 1, Pittsburgh Pirates 2
Pittsburgh Pirates 2, St. Louis Cardinals 1. The Cardinals covered the +1.5 spread despite the loss, and the game finished under the 7-run total.
St. Louis Cardinals vs. Pittsburgh Pirates final score and game recap
Thursday night at PNC Park produced a low-scoring duel between Kyle Leahy and Paul Skenes. The Cardinals struck first in the opening inning, taking a 1-0 lead. Pittsburgh answered in the bottom of the first to tie it 1-1, and both teams went silent for the next six innings. The Pirates plated the winning run in the eighth to seal a 2-1 victory.
Who covered the spread in St. Louis Cardinals vs. Pittsburgh Pirates?
St. Louis Cardinals covered the spread at +1.5. Pittsburgh entered as the -1.5 favorite but won by only one run, leaving the underdog with the against-the-spread win. The line did not move from open to close. AiQ's spread pick was St. Louis Cardinals +1.5 with 57% confidence, graded as a win.
Did St. Louis Cardinals vs. Pittsburgh Pirates go over or under the total?
The game went under the 7-run total, finishing with three combined runs. The total opened at 6.5 and moved up to 7. AiQ's pick was Under 7 with 60% confidence, resulting in a win.
How did AiQ's St. Louis Cardinals vs. Pittsburgh Pirates predictions do?
AiQ posted a 6-2 record across every graded pick.
- Moneyline: Pittsburgh Pirates at -165 — WIN (+$60.61 on a $100 bet)
- Spread: St. Louis Cardinals +1.5 — WIN
- Total: Under 7 — WIN
- Player props: 3-2
AiQ correctly identified the moneyline favorite, the spread outcome, and the low-scoring nature of the game. It missed two of five Bryan Reynolds prop bets.
St. Louis Cardinals vs. Pittsburgh Pirates player prop results
AiQ's player prop record was 3-2.
- Bryan Reynolds over 0.5 total bases at -169 — actual 0 — LOSS
- Bryan Reynolds under 0.5 runs scored at -164 — actual 0 — WIN
- Bryan Reynolds under 0.5 RBIs — actual 0 — WIN
- Bryan Reynolds under 0.5 home runs — actual 0 — WIN
- Bryan Reynolds over 0.5 hits at -175 — actual 0 — LOSS
Four of the five prop lines involved Reynolds staying below a half-unit threshold. The under picks on runs, RBIs, and home runs all hit; the over picks on total bases and hits both missed.
St. Louis Cardinals vs. Pittsburgh Pirates game prop results: first five innings and team totals
- First-five-innings total 3.5: Under (paid -110); 2 runs scored
- Pittsburgh Pirates team total 3.5: Under (paid -105); 2 runs scored
- St. Louis Cardinals team total 2.5: Under (paid +114); 1 run scored
- First-five-innings moneyline: tied, bets refunded
The early lack of offense kept both team totals and the first-half total comfortably under their respective lines.
St. Louis Cardinals vs. Pittsburgh Pirates odds: sportsbook value and line movement
The closing moneyline listed St. Louis Cardinals +136 and Pittsburgh Pirates -165, implying a 40% win probability for the Cardinals and 60% for the Pirates after vig removal. The bookmaker's margin sat at 4.6%. Pittsburgh won the moneyline at -165, paying $60.61 on a $100 wager. AiQ's pre-game expected value calculation used a -159 line, yielding -1.7% EV, so the price was negative-EV despite the side being a favorite. The market's implied 60% probability matched AiQ's calibrated estimate.
St. Louis Cardinals and Pittsburgh Pirates betting trends: 2026 season
The Cardinals sit at 77-81 after 158 games, 38-42 at home and 39-39 on the road. They are 86-72 against the spread and have finished under the total 78 times versus 72 overs. Their last five results: loss, win, loss, win, loss.
The Pirates are 81-77 through 158 contests, 44-37 at home and 37-40 away. Their against-the-spread record stands at 76-82, and they have finished over the total 81 times versus 70 unders. Their recent stretch: win, loss, win, win, win.