St. Louis Cardinals defeat Pittsburgh Pirates 5-1: Recap, Betting Results & AiQ Picks
Wed, Sep 23, 2026 · MLB · St. Louis Cardinals 5, Pittsburgh Pirates 1
St. Louis Cardinals defeated Pittsburgh Pirates 5-1, covering the +1.5 spread as an underdog. The game finished under the 7.5 total with six combined runs.
St. Louis Cardinals vs. Pittsburgh Pirates final score and game recap
The Cardinals built an early lead and never relinquished it. Pittsburgh scored a single run in the second inning, but St. Louis answered with three runs in the third inning and two more in the fourth to reach 5-1. The scoreboard read 5-1 after five innings, and neither team scored again. The Cardinals' offense concentrated its damage in innings three and four, closing out the game at PNC Park without further scoring.
Who covered the spread in St. Louis Cardinals vs. Pittsburgh Pirates?
St. Louis Cardinals covered the +1.5 spread. The spread opened at Pittsburgh Pirates +0.5 and shifted two points toward Pittsburgh, closing at Pittsburgh Pirates -1.5. AiQ had taken Pittsburgh Pirates -1.5 at 59% confidence, grading the pick at the closing line as a loss.
Did St. Louis Cardinals vs. Pittsburgh Pirates go over or under the total?
The game went under the 7.5 total, finishing with six combined runs. Scoring occurred only in the second, third, and fourth innings, leaving the total 1.5 runs shy of the line. The closing total remained 7.5. AiQ had selected the under 7 at 54% confidence, resulting in a win.
How did AiQ's St. Louis Cardinals vs. Pittsburgh Pirates predictions do?
AiQ finished 1-2 on this game.
- Moneyline: Pittsburgh Pirates -137 – LOSS
- Spread: Pittsburgh Pirates -1.5 – LOSS
- Total: Under 7 – WIN
The model correctly identified the low-scoring nature of the contest but missed both the outright winner and the spread. AiQ's moneyline estimate was -0.9% at -134, a negative-expected-value price despite the model favoring Pittsburgh; the market's implied 57% probability matched AiQ's calibrated estimate.
St. Louis Cardinals vs. Pittsburgh Pirates game prop results: team totals and first five innings
- Pittsburgh Pirates team total 3.5: Under (paid +100); they scored 1.
- St. Louis Cardinals team total 3.5: Over (paid -105); they scored 5.
- First-five-innings total 4.5: Over (paid +116); six runs were produced in the first five innings.
- First-five-innings moneyline: St. Louis Cardinals won the first five innings (paid +105).
St. Louis Cardinals vs. Pittsburgh Pirates odds: sportsbook value and line movement
The moneyline closed at St. Louis Cardinals +115 and Pittsburgh Pirates -137, implying a 45% win probability for St. Louis after vigorish removal. The vig on the line was 4.3%, and the Cardinals' +115 paid $115 on a $100 stake when they won outright. The spread shifted two points toward Pittsburgh, reflecting betting pressure.
St. Louis Cardinals and Pittsburgh Pirates betting trends: 2026 season
St. Louis Cardinals sit at 77-80 overall after 157 games, with a 38-42 home record and a 39-38 road/neutral split. They are 85-72 against the spread and 72-77-8 on the over/under in games with a recorded closing line. Their last five results: W, L, W, L, L.
Pittsburgh Pirates sit at 80-77 overall after 157 games, posting a 43-37 home record and a 37-40 away/neutral record. They are 76-81 against the spread and 81-69-7 on the over/under in games with a recorded closing line. Their last five results: L, W, W, W, W.