Arizona Diamondbacks defeat New York Yankees 5-3: Recap, Betting Results & AiQ Picks

Sat, Sep 19, 2026 · MLB · New York Yankees 3, Arizona Diamondbacks 5

Arizona defeated New York 5-3 on Saturday at Chase Field, covering the +1.5 spread while the game cleared the 7.5 total at eight combined runs.

New York Yankees vs. Arizona Diamondbacks final score and game recap

The Diamondbacks scored in bunches: two runs in the fifth inning, one in the sixth, and two more in the ninth. New York answered with one run in the fifth and two in the sixth, but could not close the gap. Starting pitchers Cam Schlittler for the Yankees and Brandon Pfaadt for the Diamondbacks set a low-scoring tone through four innings before the offense took over. The final tally: Arizona 5, New York 3.

Who covered the spread in New York Yankees vs. Arizona Diamondbacks?

Arizona Diamondbacks covered the +1.5 spread. The Yankees entered as -1.5 favorites and lost by two runs, giving the underdog an outright win. The line held at Arizona +1.5 from open to close. AiQ's spread pick was New York Yankees -1.5 at 59% confidence, graded as a loss.

Did New York Yankees vs. Arizona Diamondbacks go over or under the total?

The game went over the 7.5 total, finishing with eight runs. The total line did not move. AiQ's total pick was Over 7.5 at 54% confidence, resulting in a win.

How did AiQ's New York Yankees vs. Arizona Diamondbacks predictions do?

AiQ finished 1-2 across the graded picks.

The model correctly anticipated the over but missed both the moneyline and spread.

New York Yankees vs. Arizona Diamondbacks game prop results: team totals and first five innings

New York Yankees vs. Arizona Diamondbacks odds: sportsbook value and line movement

The closing moneyline was New York Yankees -161 and Arizona Diamondbacks +135, implying a 59% win probability for New York after removing the 4.2% vig. Arizona's victory at +135 paid $135 on a $100 wager. AiQ's pre-game moneyline expected value was -0.1% at -132, the best price found at FanDuel. The market's implied probability of 57% matched AiQ's calibrated estimate of 57%, showing alignment on the underlying win chance despite the unfavorable price.

New York Yankees are 88-64 overall in 152 games, 42-32 at home and 46-32 on the road. Their last five results are L, W, L, W, W.

Arizona Diamondbacks sit at 79-73 overall in 152 games, 42-35 at home and 37-38 away. Their last five results are W, L, L, L, W.

What's next for New York Yankees and Arizona Diamondbacks?

The New York Yankees will host the Boston Red Sox on Thursday, October 1.